Development economics (market economy formation models)

Содержание

Слайд 2

THE STRUCTURE OF THE COURSE Developmental tradition in Economics: it’s essence,

THE STRUCTURE OF THE COURSE

Developmental tradition in Economics: it’s essence, origin

and sources.
The world economy: unity of heterogeneous.
Keynesian models of economic growth.
Слайд 3

THE STRUCTURE OF THE COURSE Neoclassical models of economic development. Institutional

THE STRUCTURE OF THE COURSE

Neoclassical models of economic development.
Institutional and neo-institutional

analysis of the problems of economic modernization.
The exterior factors of economic development: their essence, types and role.
Слайд 4

THE STRUCTURE OF THE COURSE The new models of economic growth

THE STRUCTURE OF THE COURSE

The new models of economic growth

on the role of human capital.
Factor markets and the problem of poverty in developing countries.
Government and market: the problems of their interaction in developing countries.
Слайд 5

THE STRUCTURE OF THE COURSE Catching-up development in the modern world:

THE STRUCTURE OF THE COURSE

Catching-up development in the modern world: the

factors, results and problems.
Market reforms in Russia: short history, results and problems.
Слайд 6

READING LIST ON THE COURSE Herschenkron A. Economic Backwardness in Historical

READING LIST ON THE COURSE

Herschenkron A. Economic Backwardness in Historical Perspective:

A Book of Essays. Cambridge (Mass.), 1962.
Preston P. W. Theories of Development. L., 1982.
Coleman D., Nixson F. Economics of Change in Less Developed Countries. 2nd ed. Oxfard 1986
Rostow W. W. Theories of Economics Growth from David Hume to the Present. N.Y., 1992.
Слайд 7

READING LIST ON THE COURSE Rostow W. W. The Stages of

READING LIST ON THE COURSE

Rostow W. W. The Stages of Economics

Growth. A Non-communist Manifesto. Cambridge, 1960.
Leibenstein H. A. Economic Backwardness and Economic Growth. Studies in the Theory of Economic Development. N.Y., 1957.
Todaro M. P. Economic Development. 5th ed. L., 1994.
Ray D. Development Economics. Princeton, 1998.
Rosenstein-Rodan P. N. Problems of Industrialization of Eastern and South-Estern Europe // The Economic Journal. 1943. Vol. 53. June/ September.
Слайд 8

READING LIST ON THE COURSE Murphy K., Schleifer A., Vishny R.

READING LIST ON THE COURSE

Murphy K., Schleifer A., Vishny R. Industrialization

and the Big Push // Journal of Political Economy. 1989.
Hirshman A.O. The Strategy of Economic Development. 2nd ed. New Haven, 1961.
Lewis W. A. The Theory of Economic Growth. N.Y., 1959.
Myrdal G. Asian Drama: An Inquiry into the Poverty of Nations. Vol. I-III. N.Y., 1968.
Schultez T.W. Investments in Human Capital. N.Y., 1971.
Soto E. de. The Mystery of Capital. N.Y., 1995.
Слайд 9

READING LIST ON THE COURSE Soto E. de. The Other Way.

READING LIST ON THE COURSE
Soto E. de. The Other Way. N.Y.,

1987.
Prebisch R. The Economic Development of Latin America and Its Principal Problems. N.Y. 1962.
Amin S. L’échange inégale et la loi de la valeur. Paris. 1973.
Solow R. A Contribution to the Theory of Economic Growth//.Quarterly journal of Economics. 1956. February.
Becker G. Human Capital. N.Y. 1954.
Ha-Joan Chang Economics: the User’s Guide. London, Penguin Books, 2010.
Нуреев Р.М. Экономика развития: модели становления рыночной экономики. Изд. Норма, М., 2008.
Слайд 10

THEME 1. DEVELOPMENTAL TRADITION IN ECONOMICS: IT’S ESSENCE, ORIGIN AND SOURCES

THEME 1. DEVELOPMENTAL TRADITION IN ECONOMICS: IT’S ESSENCE, ORIGIN AND SOURCES

Backward countries

can not develop if they entirely rely on the market
Path dependence problem
Development tradition is not an economic school: pragmatic and eclectic character, but its eclecticism is at the same time its drawback and advantage.
Слайд 11

THEME 1. DEVELOPMENTAL TRADITION IN ECONOMICS: IT’S ESSENCE, ORIGIN AND SOURCES

THEME 1. DEVELOPMENTAL TRADITION IN ECONOMICS: IT’S ESSENCE, ORIGIN AND SOURCES

Developmental tradition

is the most important intellectual tradition in Economics: it accounts for all the successful examples of economic development in the history of mankind (GB, the USA, Germany, the modern China).
Слайд 12

THEME 1. DEVELOPMENTAL TRADITION IN ECONOMICS: IT’S ESSENCE, ORIGIN AND SOURCES

THEME 1. DEVELOPMENTAL TRADITION IN ECONOMICS: IT’S ESSENCE, ORIGIN AND SOURCES

Developmental tradition:

its origin and evolution (Henry VII, Govanni Botero, Antonio Serre, mercantilist economic school, German historical school).
Development tradition had for its goal to assist the economically backward countries to develop their economies in order to catch up the economically advanced countries.
Слайд 13

THEME 1. DEVELOPMENTAL TRADITION IN ECONOMICS: IT’S ESSENCE, ORIGIN AND SOURCES

THEME 1. DEVELOPMENTAL TRADITION IN ECONOMICS: IT’S ESSENCE, ORIGIN AND SOURCES

The followers

of the developmental tradition believed that economic development can not be reduced entirely to income maximization (the richness in natural resources may be sufficient for it).
They considered the economic development as the result of the ever more productive capacities growth.
Слайд 14

THEME 1. DEVELOPMENTAL TRADITION IN ECONOMICS: IT’S ESSENCE, ORIGIN AND SOURCES

THEME 1. DEVELOPMENTAL TRADITION IN ECONOMICS: IT’S ESSENCE, ORIGIN AND SOURCES

The followers

of the developmental tradition pointed out that the above-mentioned task can not be solved without an active state economic policy under respective forms.
Слайд 15

THEME 1. DEVELOPMENTAL TRADITION IN ECONOMICS: IT’S ESSENCE, ORIGIN AND SOURCES

THEME 1. DEVELOPMENTAL TRADITION IN ECONOMICS: IT’S ESSENCE, ORIGIN AND SOURCES

Developmental tradition

in the modern world: development economics.
Development economics as the modern stage of the developmental tradition was set up in 1950-1960 by such economists as Simon Kuznetz, Arthur Lewis, Gunnar Myrdall, Albert Hirshmann.
Слайд 16

THEME 1. DEVELOPMENTAL TRADITION IN ECONOMICS: IT’S ESSENCE, ORIGIN AND SOURCES

THEME 1. DEVELOPMENTAL TRADITION IN ECONOMICS: IT’S ESSENCE, ORIGIN AND SOURCES

Developmental tradition

is not a coherent economic theory, but it is more adaptable and practically oriented due to its ability to combine the achievements of many economic schools.
Слайд 17

THEME 1. DEVELOPMENTAL TRADITION IN ECONOMICS: IT’S ESSENCE, ORIGIN AND SOURCES

THEME 1. DEVELOPMENTAL TRADITION IN ECONOMICS: IT’S ESSENCE, ORIGIN AND SOURCES

The forth-coming

themes of our course are focused on the analysis of the main market formation economic models and the practical results of their implementation in developing countries.
Слайд 18

THEME 1I. THE WORLD ECONOMY: UNITY OF HETEROGENEOUS The collapse of

THEME 1I. THE WORLD ECONOMY: UNITY OF HETEROGENEOUS

The collapse of colonial system

resulted in the emergence of big group of independent countries. At the beginning of current century they accounted for 75% of the world population and 40% of the world GDP.
Слайд 19

THEME 1I. THE WORLD ECONOMY: UNITY OF HETEROGENEOUS These two figures

THEME 1I. THE WORLD ECONOMY: UNITY OF HETEROGENEOUS

These two figures characterize the

big and ever increasing gap between the industrially developed countries and the countries of the so-called “third world”.
At the same time the countries of the given group are not homogeneous by the criteria of the level of economic development and their place within the world economy.
Слайд 20

THEME 1I. THE WORLD ECONOMY: UNITY OF HETEROGENEOUS The heterogeneity of

THEME 1I. THE WORLD ECONOMY: UNITY OF HETEROGENEOUS

The heterogeneity of the countries

of the “third world” determined their classification into different echelons.
One of the most known classifications of this type was worked out by the American economist Alexander Gershenkron.
Слайд 21

THEME 1I. THE WORLD ECONOMY: UNITY OF HETEROGENEOUS Alexander Gershenkron (1904-1978)

THEME 1I. THE WORLD ECONOMY: UNITY OF HETEROGENEOUS

Alexander Gershenkron
(1904-1978)
Economic Backwardness in

Historical Perspective: A Book of Essays. Cambridge (Mass.), 1962.
Слайд 22

THEME 1I. THE WORLD ECONOMY: UNITY OF HETEROGENEOUS A. Gershenkron divided

THEME 1I. THE WORLD ECONOMY: UNITY OF HETEROGENEOUS

A. Gershenkron divided all the

capitalist countries into three echelons (see the next slide):
Слайд 23

THEME 1I.

THEME 1I.

Слайд 24

THEME 1I. THE WORLD ECONOMY: UNITY OF HETEROGENEOUS Besides this classification

THEME 1I. THE WORLD ECONOMY: UNITY OF HETEROGENEOUS

Besides this classification there are

many others, basing mostly on the same criteria
Practical significance of the classification of the countries.
Слайд 25

THEME 1I. THE WORLD ECONOMY: UNITY OF HETEROGENEOUS The leaders of

THEME 1I. THE WORLD ECONOMY: UNITY OF HETEROGENEOUS

The leaders of many countries

of the “third world” were inspired by the USSR experience of quick industrialization. They believed that economic backwardness could be overcome within short-run period.
Слайд 26

THEME 1I. THE WORLD ECONOMY: UNITY OF HETEROGENEOUS It was suggested

THEME 1I. THE WORLD ECONOMY: UNITY OF HETEROGENEOUS

It was suggested that the

problems of the developing countries were similar to those solved in the pasture by the nowadays developed countries.
Basing on this logic it was quite naturally to use the instruments (models) elaborated by the main economic schools (classical, neoclassical, Keynesian and neo-Keynesian), because these models proved to be efficient in developed capitalist countries.
Слайд 27

THEME 1II. KEYNESIAN MODELS OF ECONOMIC GROWTH The theory of “vicious

THEME 1II. KEYNESIAN MODELS OF ECONOMIC GROWTH

The theory of “vicious circle of

poverty”.
The founders - H. Zinger and R. Prebisch.
The main thesis: the economic backwardness is due to specific relationship between the rates of growth of population and change of GDP per capita.
Слайд 28

THEME 1II. KEYNESIAN MODELS OF ECONOMIC GROWTH It means that any

THEME 1II. KEYNESIAN MODELS OF ECONOMIC GROWTH

It means that any increase of

GDP per capita leads to ever higher increase of population, that in its turn decreases GDP per capita.
The most known variants of the this theory are:
Слайд 29

THEME 1II. KEYNESIAN MODELS OF ECONOMIC GROWTH the theory of quasi-stable

THEME 1II. KEYNESIAN MODELS OF ECONOMIC GROWTH

the theory of quasi-stable equilibrium of

H. Leibenstein (1922-1994):
The agricultural productivity growth leads to the increase of GDP per capita that is quickly annihilated by the population growth
Слайд 30

THEME 1II. KEYNESIAN MODELS OF ECONOMIC GROWTH The theory of vicious

THEME 1II. KEYNESIAN MODELS OF ECONOMIC GROWTH

The theory of vicious circle

of capital shortage of R. Nurkse (1907-1959):
the capital shortage → low labor productivity → low level income → low buying capacity → weak stimulae for investments → the capital shortage
Слайд 31

THEME 1II. KEYNESIAN MODELS OF ECONOMIC GROWTH The Keynesian interpretation of

THEME 1II. KEYNESIAN MODELS OF ECONOMIC GROWTH

The Keynesian interpretation of the vicious

circle of poverty: low level of savings → investment shortage → low production efficiency → low production profitability → low rates of economic growth → low incomes → low consumption level → low level of savings.

J. M. Keynes
(1883-1946)

Слайд 32

THEME 1II. KEYNESIAN MODELS OF ECONOMIC GROWTH The concept of the

THEME 1II. KEYNESIAN MODELS OF ECONOMIC GROWTH

The concept of the take-off into

self-sustained growth by Rostow W. (The Stages of Economic Growth. A Non-communist Manifesto):
the traditional society;
the preconditions for take-off;
the take-off;
Слайд 33

THEME 1II. KEYNESIAN MODELS OF ECONOMIC GROWTH The drive to maturity;

THEME 1II. KEYNESIAN MODELS OF ECONOMIC GROWTH

The drive to maturity;
The age of

high mass consumption;
The stage of life-quality search.
Слайд 34

THEME 1II. KEYNESIAN MODELS OF ECONOMIC GROWTH The stage classification is

THEME 1II. KEYNESIAN MODELS OF ECONOMIC GROWTH

The stage classification is based on

mostly technical-economic criteria, such as
- technological level;
- branch structure of economy;
- production accumulation share in national income;
- consumption structure etc.
Слайд 35

THEME 1II. KEYNESIAN MODELS OF ECONOMIC GROWTH In so doing, the

THEME 1II. KEYNESIAN MODELS OF ECONOMIC GROWTH

In so doing, the economic development

is reduced to high rates of growth. The theory puts the accent on the relationship between investments and GDP rates of growth and neglects the necessary social and institutional changes.
Слайд 36

THEME 1II. KEYNESIAN MODELS OF ECONOMIC GROWTH Nevertheless, W. Rostow’ s

THEME 1II. KEYNESIAN MODELS OF ECONOMIC GROWTH

Nevertheless, W. Rostow’ s theory marked

a step forward comparing with the previous theoretical views.
Слайд 37

THEME 1II. KEYNESIAN MODELS OF ECONOMIC GROWTH The theory of big

THEME 1II. KEYNESIAN MODELS OF ECONOMIC GROWTH

The theory of big push
The theory

of big push is a synthesis of two above-discussed concepts: the vicious circle of poverty and self-sustained growth.
The founder of this theory is P. Rosenstein-Roden (1943)
Слайд 38

THEME 1II. KEYNESIAN MODELS OF ECONOMIC GROWTH In accordance with his

THEME 1II. KEYNESIAN MODELS OF ECONOMIC GROWTH

In accordance with his views and

the views of his followers (R. Nurkse, G. Zinger, A. Hirshman), the developing countries needed the initial industrialization.
This problem was considered from the neo-Keynesian point of view.
Слайд 39

THEME 1II. KEYNESIAN MODELS OF ECONOMIC GROWTH The first economists of

THEME 1II. KEYNESIAN MODELS OF ECONOMIC GROWTH

The first economists of the given

school that contributed to the solution of this problem where R. Harrod and E. Domar (1939-1949).
Both of them are the authors of the economic models called: Domar’s model and Harrod’s model.
Both models are mutually complementary, though there are some differences between them.
Слайд 40

THEME 1II. KEYNESIAN MODELS OF ECONOMIC GROWTH In accordance with the

THEME 1II. KEYNESIAN MODELS OF ECONOMIC GROWTH

In accordance with the Keynesian tradition,

the authors considered investments as the instrument to control the economic growth.
Слайд 41

THEME 1II. KEYNESIAN MODELS OF ECONOMIC GROWTH Studies on Economic Growth Euvsey Domar (1914-1997) Euvsey Domar

THEME 1II. KEYNESIAN MODELS OF ECONOMIC GROWTH

Studies on Economic Growth

Euvsey Domar (1914-1997)

Euvsey

Domar
Слайд 42

THEME 1II. KEYNESIAN MODELS OF ECONOMIC GROWTH

THEME 1II. KEYNESIAN MODELS OF ECONOMIC GROWTH

 

Слайд 43

THEME 1II. KEYNESIAN MODELS OF ECONOMIC GROWTH

THEME 1II. KEYNESIAN MODELS OF ECONOMIC GROWTH

 

Слайд 44

THEME 1II. KEYNESIAN MODELS OF ECONOMIC GROWTH In so doing the

THEME 1II. KEYNESIAN MODELS OF ECONOMIC GROWTH


 

In so doing the increase

of the aggregate supply may be represented in the following way:
Слайд 45

THEME 1II. KEYNESIAN MODELS OF ECONOMIC GROWTH

THEME 1II. KEYNESIAN MODELS OF ECONOMIC GROWTH

 

Слайд 46

THEME 1II. KEYNESIAN MODELS OF ECONOMIC GROWTH R. Harrod (1900-1978)

THEME 1II. KEYNESIAN MODELS OF ECONOMIC GROWTH

R. Harrod (1900-1978)

Слайд 47

THEME 1II. KEYNESIAN MODELS OF ECONOMIC GROWTH Unlike Domar’s model where

THEME 1II. KEYNESIAN MODELS OF ECONOMIC GROWTH

Unlike Domar’s model where the investments

were considered as an exogenous factor, in Harrod’s model investments have endogenous character
Слайд 48

THEME 1II. KEYNESIAN MODELS OF ECONOMIC GROWTH if I = S, than aggregate demand is:

THEME 1II. KEYNESIAN MODELS OF ECONOMIC GROWTH

 

 

 

 

if I = S, than aggregate

demand is:
Слайд 49

THEME 1II. KEYNESIAN MODELS OF ECONOMIC GROWTH Equilibrium economic growth presupposes that AD = AS:

THEME 1II. KEYNESIAN MODELS OF ECONOMIC GROWTH

 

Equilibrium economic growth presupposes that AD

= AS:
Слайд 50

THEME 1II. KEYNESIAN MODELS OF ECONOMIC GROWTH

THEME 1II. KEYNESIAN MODELS OF ECONOMIC GROWTH

 

Слайд 51

THEME 1II. KEYNESIAN MODELS OF ECONOMIC GROWTH If AD = AS, a = 1, then

THEME 1II. KEYNESIAN MODELS OF ECONOMIC GROWTH

 

 

If AD = AS, a =

1, then
Слайд 52

THEME 1II. KEYNESIAN MODELS OF ECONOMIC GROWTH

THEME 1II. KEYNESIAN MODELS OF ECONOMIC GROWTH

 

Слайд 53

THEME 1II. KEYNESIAN MODELS OF ECONOMIC GROWTH Nowadays both Harrod’s and

THEME 1II. KEYNESIAN MODELS OF ECONOMIC GROWTH

Nowadays both Harrod’s and Domar’s models

are considered as one single model that is used by Keynesian school to substantiate the theory of big push.
The model in spite of its drawbacks proved the doubtless linkage between the rates of investments growth and the rates of GDP growth
Слайд 54

THEME 1II. KEYNESIAN MODELS OF ECONOMIC GROWTH H. Leibenstein pointed out

THEME 1II. KEYNESIAN MODELS OF ECONOMIC GROWTH

H. Leibenstein pointed out that in

order to initiate the big push, the level of investments should not be less than 12-15% of the national income.
The sufficient inflow of investments will increase the rate of growth of per capita income.
In so doing, there will be the increase of buying capacity population and aggregate demand.
Слайд 55

THEME 1II. KEYNESIAN MODELS OF ECONOMIC GROWTH In the long run

THEME 1II. KEYNESIAN MODELS OF ECONOMIC GROWTH

In the long run the increase

of demand will stimulate the entrepreneurial activity in the country and the economic growth.
The big push theory is a macroeconomic theory. It points out that the economic and social backwardness of the developing countries is mostly the result of capital shortage.
Слайд 56

THEME 1II. KEYNESIAN MODELS OF ECONOMIC GROWTH The leaders of many

THEME 1II. KEYNESIAN MODELS OF ECONOMIC GROWTH

The leaders of many developing countries

assumed skeptical attitude towards the self-regulated function of the market.
They believed that what their countries needed, were deep structural changes in the main branches of national economy.
Слайд 57

THEME 1II. KEYNESIAN MODELS OF ECONOMIC GROWTH R. Nurkse who supported

THEME 1II. KEYNESIAN MODELS OF ECONOMIC GROWTH

R. Nurkse who supported the discussed

theory, offered the model of the balanced set of investments as the precondition to launch the process of industrialization simultaneously across the whole economy.
Later on this idea was developed in the works of such economist as Murphy K., Schleifer A. and Vishny R.
Слайд 58

THEME 1II. KEYNESIAN MODELS OF ECONOMIC GROWTH The theory of the

THEME 1II. KEYNESIAN MODELS OF ECONOMIC GROWTH

The theory of the balanced set

of investments was sharply criticized, because of its unrealistic character: it is not possible to coordinate the investment process in the whole economy in the absence of the centralized planning body. That’s why finally instead of balanced set of investments there will be macroeconomic imbalance and the failure of industrialization.
Слайд 59

THEME 1II. KEYNESIAN MODELS OF ECONOMIC GROWTH Albert O. Hirschman (1915-2012)

THEME 1II. KEYNESIAN MODELS OF ECONOMIC GROWTH

Albert O. Hirschman
(1915-2012)
The Strategy of economic

development (1957)
Слайд 60

THEME 1II. KEYNESIAN MODELS OF ECONOMIC GROWTH Albert O. Hirschman was

THEME 1II. KEYNESIAN MODELS OF ECONOMIC GROWTH

Albert O. Hirschman was one the

leading critics of the above-discussed model. His main counter argument was the shortage of sufficient capitals in the developing countries.
That’s why he offered the concept (model) of imbalanced economic growth.
Слайд 61

THEME 1II. KEYNESIAN MODELS OF ECONOMIC GROWTH His logic was the

THEME 1II. KEYNESIAN MODELS OF ECONOMIC GROWTH

His logic was the following:
Initial

investments → imbalance → stimulae for new investments → new investments → new disequilibrium → new disequilibrium as the stimulate for new investments.
Слайд 62

THEME 1II. KEYNESIAN MODELS OF ECONOMIC GROWTH The Hirshman’s model emphasizes

THEME 1II. KEYNESIAN MODELS OF ECONOMIC GROWTH

The Hirshman’s model emphasizes that many

branches in any national economies are mutually interconnected between themselves.
Слайд 63

THEME 1II. KEYNESIAN MODELS OF ECONOMIC GROWTH So if the government

THEME 1II. KEYNESIAN MODELS OF ECONOMIC GROWTH

So if the government provides the

support (f. e. financial) to some of them, it provokes the chain reaction in the whole national economy: the stimulated branches become the points of growth.
Слайд 64

THEME 1II. KEYNESIAN MODELS OF ECONOMIC GROWTH G. Myrdal and H.

THEME 1II. KEYNESIAN MODELS OF ECONOMIC GROWTH

G. Myrdal and H. Zinger as

the critics of Hirshman’s concept.
Слайд 65

THEME 1II. KEYNESIAN MODELS OF ECONOMIC GROWTH Two gaps model (Chenery

THEME 1II. KEYNESIAN MODELS OF ECONOMIC GROWTH

Two gaps model (Chenery H., Bruno

M.): the economic development is the result of the squeezing out the exterior sources of investments and their replacement by endogenous (domestic) sources.
Obviously this model ignored the existing shortage of capital in the developing countries.
Слайд 66

THEME 1II. KEYNESIAN MODELS OF ECONOMIC GROWTH The Keynesian’ models of

THEME 1II. KEYNESIAN MODELS OF ECONOMIC GROWTH

The Keynesian’ models of economic growth

were popular in the post-war period (1950-1960). But gradually it became ever more evident that they could not be considered as an effective instrument to accelerate economic growth and to overcome the backwardness of developing countries.